The Political Round-Up
Ro, ro, robo the vote;
In Baldwin, is hard rain a-gonna fall?;
Bermuda Triangle; Solutions in Motion;
Twinkle, Twinkle Eastern Shore;
Small business backing
By Chip Drago
Mobile Bay Times
An amended campaign finance report has been filed to reflect hundreds of thousands of AEA-sponsored "robo-calls" in support of Dr. Robert Bentley's successful bid to win the GOP nomination for governor from his runoff rival Bradley Byrne, according to Alabama Education Association executive director Paul Hubbert.
Emails between AEA staffers and erstwhile Bentley backer Stan Pate detail a plan between July 8-11 to counter a Byrne offensive, including an avalanche of public endorsements from leading Alabama GOP figures.
The arrangement opened with an email from Nick Bailey, whom Pate hired to work for his Tuscaloosa-based real estate company following the former Siegelman administration factotum's release from prison. Assigned a "high" importance, Bailey's email to Pate and Joan Whitbeck on July 8 at 10:29 a.m. advised that "David Stout with Dr. Hubbert will be calling Stan shortly at Dr. Hubbert's request."
Stout is public relations director for AEA.
Exactly an hour later, Pate got an email from Stout confirming that Pate could operate as a sub-account under AEA's relationship with DialMyCalls.com. Pate was alerted to watch for an email from the company. But apparently DialMyCalls' wastes no time because the email to Pate outlining its procedures and features had gone out two minutes before Stout informed Pate to watch for it.
The next day -- Friday, July 9 -- Stout emailed Pate the wording for a "potential ROBO call via AEA" to counter Byrne's "negative (ads) and endorsements from the Riley establishment."
The suggested copy read: "This is Doctor Robert Bentley. This weekend you may receive a variety of misleading phone calls, push polls, and negative messages about my campaign. These faceless, nameless voice (sic) will try to mislead you into thinking I am something other than what I have always been: that is, a true conservative, pro business, pro life, pro family Republican. You may also hear about endorsement from politicians of one sort or another. The only endorsement that I ask is yours. I ask for your vote and your help on Tuesday. This is Doctor Robert Bentley. Thank you for listening."
Stout forwarded the draft of a second proposed Bentley robo-call, telling Pate: "I have everything set up for the calls. I need some lead time to notify the vendor because of the large number of calls that have to be processed. If we know the schedule it would help. Should we plan for a Saturday call, Monday call, and Tuesday call? Thanks."
The proposed 73-word call read: "This is Doctor Robert Bentley calling to ask for your vote (this Tuesday). As Governor I will make job creation my number one priority. I will not take a salary until we reach full employment. I will clean up the mess in Montgomery and I pledge to run an open administration with high ethical and moral standards. With your support, we'll win this election and make government work for the people. Thank you."
Bentley's message in the robo-calls doesn't conflict with his pledge not to indulge in negative campaigning. He reaffirmed that pledge on June 28 in a press release:
Dr. Robert Bentley reaffirmed his pledge today to run a positive, issue-based campaign, and made clear he opposes all negative ads regardless of who they are paid for by.
"I hold myself responsible for my campaign and my campaign won't run any negative ads. I do not authorize or condone any negative advertising by any party and my campaign won't run any," Bentley said.
Dr. Bentley continued: "Negative ads won't put a single Alabamian back to work - let's focus on the real challenges affecting Alabamians - fighting the intrusion of the federal government, creating jobs, and cleaning up Montgomery."
Without overlooking Pate's reputation as a maverick, the robo-calls and emails suggest a closer relationship between AEA and the Bentley campaign than Bentley has acknowledged.
On Sunday afternoon, July 11, with Election Day looming and polls fewer than 40 hours away from opening, Stout reported the results of the robo-calls to Hubbert, Stephen Martin, Mary Ogles, Paul Johnson, Amy Marlowe and Gerald Johnson, with Pate copied.
The Friday "blast" led to 204,832 live answers, 224,650 answering machines, 100,844 no answer/bad number and 10,805 busy signals. Of 541,131 calls placed, 429,482 were deemed "successful."
A Saturday blast was similar, ending with 541,131 attempts and 428,573 "successful" connections.
The cost of robo phone blasts are typically about seven or eight cents per call, according to industry veterans.
"We filed an amended report after discovering that our original one had failed to list this in-kind contribution," Hubbert noted.
The Bentley campaign also reacted to have its filings with the Secretary of State's office reflect the transaction, sending an amended report on Wednesday.
"When we first learned of an in-kind contribution, made by an independent third party, we amended our Financial Disclosure Report to reflect that immediately and submitted it to the Secretary of State's office," advised Rebekah Mason of the Bentley campaign.
A-VOTE, a "pacronym" for Alabama Voice of Teachers for Education, whose treasurer is Hubbert, showed expenditures on July 8 to On Time Telecom of $13,730.81 for non-specific advertising and $20,769.19 as an in-kind contribution to the Bentley campaign.
Bentley's 45-day pre-election disclosure includes an in-kind contribution from A-Vote, an AEA political action committee, of $20,769.19 for advertising.
Pate did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Though he had been told of the emails and their contents, Byrne had not seen them and thus, without first hand knowledge, preferred not to comment, he said.
A former state senator, Byrne accepted Riley's offer to head the state's two-year college system as chancellor. The job gave Byrne a statewide platform to intensify his criticism of AEA and Hubbert and the ills they purportedly inflict on education, society and the political system in Alabama. Hubbert took umbrage. The two became engaged in a titanic tussle -- King of the Alabama Political Hill. Hubbert, as a vice chairman of the state Democratic Party and once its standard bearer as gubernatorial nominee himself, directed his political resources against Byrne in stealthy ways that have only recently come to light and drew criticism for his involvement in a GOP primary. Hubbert has defended his defense of AEA against its harshest critic, availing himself only of the weapons permitted to all Alabama's political gladiators according to their means. He also resigned his Democratic Party post to remove any clear-cut charge of partisanship against the AEA. The AEA claims extensive cross-party membership.
Long a critic of Riley and the Riley administration, Pate has since had a falling out with Bentley. Pate held no formal role in the Bentley campaign, but he did provide the Tuscaloosa dermatologist with office space as an in-kind contribution until their recent rift.
While whatever succor AEA provided Bentley in his contest with Byrne was one-sided, AEA appears to have taken a different tack in the general election, contributing at least $105,000 directly to Democratic nominee Ron Sparks during the reporting period.
Oops, Sparks gets do-over
Democratic gubernatorial nominee Ron Sparks, who missed a previously scheduled appearance here due to a conflict, will address an open meeting of the Eastern Shore Democrats Sunday, Oct. 17 from 6-8 p.m. at the Homestead Village Wellness Center ballroom in Fairhope.
Voters in Baldwin County giving ambitious
stormwater management plan the skunk eye
Stormwater management doesn't score high as a sexy political issue, but it can be compared to high blood pressure in the health of a community -- just because you don't pay attention to it doesn't mean it can't kill your quality of life.
In these tough economic times with confidence in government flagging, Baldwin County's political leadership is either brave or foolhardy to advance a proposal for addressing stormwater management before voters in a Nov. 2 referendum. Although the measure carries no immediate additional financial burden for taxpayers, Local Amendment One would create a countywide public corporation for financing comprehensive stormwater management.
With many municipalities and one of the largest counties east of the Mississippi River, Baldwin County has operated "catch as catch can" on issues of erosion, flooding and water quality. Commercial and residential development over the past 30 years has changed the rural face of Baldwin County and strained and degraded its water resources.
Will voters respond with approval as they did with a contentious school tax measure earlier this year? Most Baldwin political insiders and elected officials project that public disaffection with government and quasi-government initiatives will swamp the storm water measure. However, many, who also understand the mistrust of voters but still favor the move, say the impending defeat should be viewed much like the persistent salesman with a good product views a rejection -- just a necessary step on the way to closing a sale.
"As you can imagine, given the oil spill, the economic recession, and general mistrust of government, passage of this amendment is going to be tough," concedes Roberta Swann, director of the Mobile Bay National Estuary Program, in an email.
Opposition, naturally, forms around the imposition of a service charge, or fee, on property owners. The charge would be calculated based upon the amount of impervious area, or paved surface, that generates the runoff. The City of Mobile in the late 1980's pushed a similar plan with a similar basis for financing the expense. However, blowback from real estate developers was fierce and the politicians were quickly routed and fled from the plan in full retreat.
The Baldwin County measure has been dubbed "a rain tax," sowing confusion that officials seek to tax "a gift from God," according to Swann.
"But that's not it at all," Swann notes. "The problem is that as Baldwin County communities have grown, the amount of hard surface has increased, prohibiting rain from infiltrating into the soil in the manner in which nature intended. Instead, the rain hitting the hard surfaces -- roofs, sidewalks, roads, parking lots -- runs across the surface in greater speeds and volumes (since it couldn't soak into the ground) toward streams, creeks, and rivers. The result -- more water traveling at faster speeds -- is degrading these environmental assets, causing erosion, debris, and other pollutants to choke these habitats on their way to polluting Mobile Bay and ultimately the Gulf."
The potential for an increased burden on taxpayers has rallied opponents under a "Vote No for the Rain Tax" banner.
Swann soft-pedaled the potential for new assessments against property owners.
"The vote would only give our delegation permission to take a forward step through the creation of the local law," she points out. "A vote 'yes' on the amendment would not automatically result in a fee being levied. It would only give the Baldwin County community another option- that of creating a public corporation- should all other measures (including Baldwin County and the municipalities committing to "doing more") fail."
If the amendment fails, Baldwin County would be set back for years in its efforts to harness stormwater runoff and arrest further damage to the county's streams, rivers, creeks, the bay and even the Gulf, according to Swann.
Furthermore, the threat of greater federal involvement, in the form of the EPA, will surely follow rejection of attempts at local solutions, said Swann.
"If the County votes to keep the status quo, we can look forward to having EPA tell us what to do, instead of the community taking charge of itself," Swann added.
"Figuring out how to manage stormwater in Baldwin County is not going to be easy," she continued. "It is going to require 14 municipalities, the County, the State and a host of private interests to work together to improve the regulations, standards and criteria dictating development; to educate the community about how to keep more stormwater runoff on their properties; and most importantly to fix what is broke, the many waterways that have degraded, the infrastructure that has been compromised, and the water quality that is being impaired by the flush of pollution and sediment being deposited."
It is an irony of the issue, according to Swann, that Amendment One opponents cite the failure of government while the proposal itself does more to minimize the role of government and involve the public more directly in the costs and actions of the corporation.
Not all Baldwin countians are sold on the initiative.
"Here we go again," one critic responded. "I guess since it was so easy to get the penny tax for the schools, the environmental radicals decided they needed a slush fund, too."
"Resistance is not futile," he exhorted, referring property owners to a website -- www.smashthetax.com.
Baldwin County real estate developer Larry Chason, also a member of the county's stormwater management committee, acknowledged that Amendment One proponents were swimming against a strong current of anti-government sentiment. However, he said, the problem is too big for any one of the county's 15 governmental bodies to address and too acute to ignore much longer.
Chason chided the naysayers: "If you think one design for stormwater detention works for ALL of Baldwin County, IT DOES NOT. If you think Mayors and Council people understand how the current system has failed, THEY DO NOT. If you think that the Federal Environmental Protection Agency is not about to whack Alabama for their lack of effort to address the problem, THEY ARE. If you think there is sufficient coordination between the Cities on this issue, THERE IS NOT. If you think the amendment will set a fee or establish a new level of bureaucracy, IT DOES NOT. If you don't think there is anything wrong with the quality of the waters in this County, YOU ARE WRONG. If you want to ride on the wave that every idea is bad, then go ahead. What you will get is a steadily diminishing quality of water, followed by lower property values, polluted swimming water, non-edible seafood, eroded streams, flooding and costly repairs to roads and homes. If that's what you want, then vote no and stay with what you have. Voting "yes" on Amendment 1 is the first step towards protecting the most important thing that makes Baldwin County a special place to live."
Democratic nominee for attorney general James Anderson called it his campaign's day in the "Bermuda Triangle." He was referring to a Tuesday, Oct. 12 itinerary that took him from a breakfast meeting in Montgomery to a Rotary Club luncheon in Dothan to an early evening fundraising reception in Mobile and back to headquarters in Montgomery later than night. And sure enough, in a telephone conversation as the candidate for statewide office in Alabama drove through Florida en route to Mobile, he disappeared as the call was dropped a couple of times along the way.
But Anderson later referred to his campaign's dilemma in a way that called to mind another metaphorical Bermuda Triangle -- the exodus of white conservatives from the Democratic Party rolls in Alabama and across the South.
Anderson knows he must draw support from voters who in recent times have migrated to the Republican side of the ballot. He is straining mightily to emphasize his mainstream background that doesn't differ markedly from those voters, except, he says, for his label as a Democrat and their alienation from national Democratic Party policies. Of course, GOP nominee Luther Strange would point out that a Democrat is a Democrat. Anderson hopes to frame the debate not over the Republican/Democrat labels but over Washington insider/experienced Alabama public servant labels. He hammers Strange at every opportunity as a lobbyist, not a lawyer, while pointing to his own extensive courtroom background.
Anderson said he knows that partisan politics will ebb and flow with first this party and then that party in vogue, so that timing is important to a prospect's decision to run. Still, a person who would be a public servant has to offer himself and his record for service to the public rather than try to time it in service to his own political ambitions. According to Anderson, his son, a student at Cumberland School of Law, was recently telling him of his internal debate over whether to offer himself for a class leadership position or instead direct his time and energies to extracurricular activities that might add more value to his commercial potential. Anderson said he gave his son the "father talk" that opportunities to contribute come along only so often and if he could serve his class rather than himself, he likely would not regret it. Satisfied, Anderson ended the call. He said just afterward, he realized he needed himself to practice what he preached and called his son back to inform him that he had decided to run for attorney general.
Anderson cited Bill Baxley as his model for a successful Alabama Attorney General. If he wins, said Anderson, among his early moves will be the beef up the AG office's environmental and consumer protection divisions.
"Bill brought in good lawyers who wanted to give back to the state, some great lawyers," said Anderson. "Bill took on big challenges. He did a great job with that office. I think Charlie Graddick did a good job with that office. He brought in some good, bold fresh attorneys and they went after some folks that needed going after."
While he would not have a vote on campaign finance reform in Alabama, Anderson said he, as attorney general, would most certainly have a voice on the issue.
Cummings takes to the street
City Council District 6 candidate Reid Cummings Friday will roll out his campaign headquarters on wheels, dubbed "Solutions in Motion," at 3 p.m. from Medal of Honor Park at Hillcrest Road.
Cummings, John Burns and Bess Rich are vying in a Nov. 2 special election to win the remainder of out-going City Councilwoman Connie Hudson's term. Burns is a first-time seeker of public office, while Rich is a political veteran, having served two terms at the District 6 City Council representatives as well as chairing the Mobile Area Board of Water and Sewer Commissioners.
Twinkle, twinkle, Eastern Shore
Republican Public Service Commission nominee Twinkle Cavanaugh will address a luncheon meeting of Eastern Shore Republican Women Wednesday, Oct. 20 at 11:30 a.m. at the Fairhope Yacht Club.
Guests and prospective members are welcome. Lunch is $16. Reservations should be made no later than Monday, Oct. 18 to email@example.com.
Small business group endorses candidates
The National Federation of Independent Business, Alabama’s leading small business association, has endorsed GOP gubernatorial nominee Dr. Robert Bentley and a bi-partisan slate of candidates in 80 state legislative races, including locally:
- incumbent state Sens. Trip Pittman of Montrose; Rusty Glover of Semmes; and Ben Brooks of Mobile; and
- incumbent state Reps. Harry Shiver (Bay Minette); Alan Baker (Brewton); Joe Faust (Fairhope); Steve McMillan (Gulf Shores); Randy Davis (Daphne); Victor Gaston (Mobile); Jamie Ison (Mobile); Chad Fincher (Semmes); Jim Barton (Mobile); and Spencer Collier (Irvington).
“Our members support candidates who support small business, regardless of party affiliation,” said Rosemary Elebash, state director of NFIB/Alabama. “Small business is the backbone of Alabama’s economy, and it’s critically important to have a Legislature that supports free enterprise.”